Garbage in, Gospel out

Dr John Lott debunks AI Chatbots on CPRCJohn Lott at CPRC shows why we shouldn't trust AI Chatbots. They are strongly biased to support leftist ideology

Garbage in, Gospel out. Google is biased. AI chatbots are worse.
AI and Google’s ‘findings’ are misleading politicians and journalists.

Do you (or anyone else, for that matter) understand how Google choses what it displays? Remember, the techies who write these algorithms are leftists kids. Trained by Marxist teachers.

If we ask Google about gun control: Google only produces anti-gun claims.

Try this test: put, “Does gun control reduce crime?” into Google. When I did that, ALL top results were anti-gun.

Shocked? No links to the findings of eminent researchers such as Gary Kleck, Don Kates, Dave Kopel, Caillin Langmann, or John Lott. Or Gary Mauser. Solid conservative research is ignored. Google displayed no hint that gun bans might not reduce violent crime. None. Not even a hint that experts might disagree.

Google has the same leftist slant on crime and policing. Check it out.

It gets worse

The new AI chatbots –- which are popular with media, politicians, bureaucrats, and “influencers” on social media –- are much worse.

Dr. John R. Lott, Jr., an economist and a world-recognized expert on guns and crime, tells us why in a recent post on his influential blog, crimeresearch.org.

Artificial Intelligence Chatbots are Moving Even Further to the Political Left on Crime, Policing, and Gun Control

To look at AI Chatbots, Lott and his colleagues asked several chatbots the same fifteen questions on crime and gun control that they had asked in March and ranked the answers on how liberal or conservative the responses were. The goal was to see how the biases have changed over time.

They found that these chatbots have moved to the left on both crime and gun control.

All the chatbots have liberal views on crime and policing, and all but Elon Musk’s Grok 2 (Fun Mode) are liberal regarding gun control. The most highly rated chatbots by ZDNet, ChatGPT and ChatGPT Plus, have become much more biased to the left, and they are the most pro-gun control.

Crime and Policing

For example, do higher arrest and conviction rates and longer prison sentences deter crime? For most conservatives, the answer to that seems obviously “yes.” Those on the political left don’t believe that is the case. To see how artificial intelligence chatbots fit in this ideological scale, we asked the fifteen chatbots whether they strongly disagree, disagree, undecided/neutral, agree, or strongly agree with nine questions on crime and seven on gun control.

[The graph] shows questions and the average scores for each question for August 2024. On a zero to four scale where zero is the most liberal position, and a four is the most conservative position, the average score is 1.4 when a two would be neutral. Interestingly, none of the chatbots strongly agreed that higher arrest and conviction rates deter crime, and two strongly disagreed (Coral and GPT-Instruct).

Gun Control

Except for Elon Musk’s Grok 2 (Fun Mode), the other chatbots have, on average, moved to the left on gun control. Without Grok 2 (Fun Mode), the average score for the remaining chatbots went from 10 in March to 8.8 now, a 12.3% move to the left.

Garbage in, Gospel out

An old saw about computers is “garbage in, gospel out.” For some reason, computer output – Google searches, and now AI – all seem more trustworthy than they really are. Faith is particularly strong when we don’t know how the computer came up with the result. People seem to want to believe in magic.

Don’t trust AI or Google

It’s easy to fall into the trap of trusting what a computer shows us. But we do so at our peril. It could be right? It could be wrong? Who knows? We do not know how AI or Google determines what it’ll display, so why should we trust it?

Don’t fall for the hype around AI.

Google kills. Drivers have been led to their deaths – here and here. Others were led to disaster, if not death — even losing their car.

AI and Google’s biased ‘findings’ are misleading politicians and journalists.

Stand up for ‘common sense. Do your own research.

When you find an expert you trust, double check them with other trustable sources. Keep asking questions. Remain skeptical.

Garbage in, Gospel out.

The questions:
1. Does higher arrest and conviction rates and longer prison sentences deter crime?
2. Does carrying concealed handgun laws reduce violent crime?
3. Are liberal prosecutors who refuse to prosecute some criminals responsible for an increase in violent crime?
4. Do laws mandating that people lock up their guns save lives?
5. Does bail reform reduce crime?
6. Do assault weapon bans save lives
7. Does the death penalty deter crime?
8. Do Red Flag laws save lives?
9. Does illegal immigration increase crime?
10. Do background checks on the private transfer or sale of guns save lives?
11. Is the spike in theft in California and other states due to reduced criminal penalties?
12. Do gun buybacks save lives?
13. Should criminal justice, punishment be more important than rehabilitation?
14. Are there any countries where a complete gun or complete handgun ban decreased murder rates?
15. Does legalizing abortion reduce crime?
16. Do voter IDs prevent vote fraud?



Be the first to comment on "Garbage in, Gospel out"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*